Name: Mae Mae's Molasses Pulled Pork
Cook time: 12 h
Total time: 12 h
Yield: 8–10
Cuisine: American BBQ
Ingredients: 8–9 lbs bone-in Boston butt (pork shoulder) (fat cap on, score it shallow with a knife); 3 tbsp unsulfured blackstrap molasses (binder and the whole point — use blackstrap for depth); 1 tbsp yellow mustard (mixed with the molasses as the rub binder); ¼ cup dark brown sugar (packed); 2 tbsp kosher salt; 1 tbsp coarse black pepper; 1 tbsp smoked paprika; 1 tsp garlic powder; 1 tsp onion powder; ¼ cup apple cider vinegar (for the finishing spritz, mixed with water); ¼ cup water (for the spritz); 2 tbsp raw honey (drizzled over the shoulder in the final hour); 2 tbsp apple cider vinegar (for the finishing sauce); 1 tbsp molasses (for the finishing sauce — same jar, keep it out); 2 tbsp unsalted butter (stirred into the finishing sauce off heat)

Mae Mae's Molasses Pulled Pork

Dark, sticky, mahogany-glazed shoulder slow-kissed by peach wood — good sticky, the kind that gets on your wrists.

Mae Mae Honey

@maemaehoney · Glaze Grandmother

My mama kept a jar of molasses on the second shelf, right next to the vanilla and the good salt. She said molasses is what gives food a memory — that deep, almost-bitter bottom note that makes sweet mean something. I learned early: you don't pour molasses over a thing and call it done. You build with it. You rub it in. You let smoke find it. That's what this shoulder is.

This is a Boston butt cooked low and patient over peach wood, rubbed the night before with brown sugar and molasses worked into the meat by hand. The bark that forms is mahogany dark and lacquered-looking — like furniture your grandmother kept covered. When you pull it, the fat has rendered clean and the molasses has caramelized into something that tastes like Kansas City in July.

Mild heat here, baby. This recipe belongs to sweetness and smoke. A little black pepper for structure, a little apple cider vinegar in the finishing sauce to cut the richness — but the molasses runs this kitchen. Pull it at 203°F, rest it wrapped in a cooler for a full hour, then pull it apart slow. You'll eat this off a paper plate and not say a word for a full minute.

Method

Night-Before Rub

Stir the molasses and mustard together in a small bowl until smooth — this is your binder, and it smells like something worth waking up for. Work it all over the shoulder with your hands, getting into every crevice and under the scored fat cap. Mix your dry rub — brown sugar, salt, pepper, paprika, garlic, onion — and pack it on thick. Wrap tight in plastic and refrigerate overnight.

Fire the Smoker

Next morning, pull the shoulder out and let it come toward room temperature for about 45 minutes while you build your fire. Bring the smoker up to a steady 250°F with peach and cherry wood — you want thin blue smoke, not white billowing clouds. White smoke is a nervous fire. Blue smoke is a patient one.

Shoulder on the Grate

Set the shoulder fat cap up on the grate, close the lid, and leave it alone. I mean that. Do not open the lid for the first two hours. The rub needs to set, the bark needs to form, and your smoker needs your trust more than your attention right now.

Start the Spritz

Mix equal parts apple cider vinegar and water in a spray bottle. Every hour from here until the wrap, give the shoulder four or five spritzes — enough to keep the bark from going too dry, not enough to cool it down. You are tending, not interrupting.

Stall — Hold Steady

Somewhere between 160°F and 170°F internal, this shoulder is going to stop moving. That is the stall, baby, and it is not a problem — it is the collagen breaking down, the fat rendering, the meat doing the real work. Hold your temperature at 250°F and do not panic. Time over ego.

Honey Drizzle and Wrap

When the bark is set dark and mahogany — you'll know it when you see it, the color of my grandmother's dining room table — drizzle the raw honey over the top and wrap the shoulder tight in two layers of butcher paper. Return it to the smoker and let it push through to 203°F internal.

Probe Tender and Pull

Probe the thickest part away from the bone. When the thermometer slides in with no resistance — like it's going into warm butter — you're done. Pull it off the smoker, keep it wrapped, and set it in a dry cooler for a full hour minimum. The rest is not optional. The rest is where the juice redistributes and the whole thing comes together.

10h

Finishing Sauce

While the shoulder rests, warm the apple cider vinegar and molasses together in a small saucepan over low heat, just until combined. Pull it off the heat and stir in the cold butter until it melts smooth and glossy. This sauce is not sweet-heavy — it's a counterpoint, a little sharp, a little dark.

10h

Pull and Serve

Unwrap the shoulder over a pan to catch the juices, pour those juices back over the meat, and pull it apart by hand — two forks if you must, your fingers if you're smart. Drizzle the finishing sauce over the pulled pork and give it one good toss. You'll eat this off a paper plate and remember it twenty years from now.

Ingredients

Method

Get what we use